In this study, flexure properties of Repurposed Discontinuous Fiber Composites (R-DFCs) are investigated. Laminates were made by the Composite Recycling Technology Center using repurposed thermoset prepreg. These laminates consisted of three thicknesses, two platelets of different length, and hybrid layups where continuous fiber plies were added on the surfaces of a R-DFC core. To understand the relation between the mesostructure and the flexure modulus, finite element simulations and X-ray Computed Tomography were performed. From three point bending tests, it is seen that with an increase in platelet length, the flexure properties increase, however the Coefficient of Variation (CoV) increases at the same time. In contrast, the CoV decreases with an increase in coupon thickness, however it remains high. At a minimum, the CoV of the flexure strength of the R-DFC specimen was 19.15%. By adding continuous fiber plies, not only was there an increase in flexure modulus and strength, but the CoV of the flexure strength decreased significantly to as low as 8.61%. The results presented in this study showcase the high variability of R-DFCs and provide a method to reduce this by adding continuous fiber plies. By adding continuous fiber plies to the surface, the manufacturability of R-DFCs was retained while having a significant decrease in CoV. With the control of the CoV, these hybrid continuous–discontinuous systems can be utilized in secondary structural applications.